I teach Speech/Public Speaking (we just started calling in Oral Communication. It’s all the same). I have the class do an exercise where they think of a conversation or situation they’d like to do over. And then I have them do it over. Because I am obsessed with shit I said/did, wrongs against me from 1988. If only I could have done, would have said. If only. But usually there’s no opportunity because sometimes it’s a random person on the train versus a family member or someone I see regularly.
Years ago, I was standing on the metro platform and as the train approached I started walking toward the doors. A woman beside me was standing still, so I’m sure it appeared to her that I was simply trying to get in front of her or get on before her. Neither was true. She said, while looking at me then rolling her eyes, “Ignorant.” To this day I wish I would have said something other than, “Who’re you talking to?” Because 1. I think it came out “Who you talking to” instead and 2. I have so many words. I remember glancing at her as we rode and she was already looking at me. She did this “What” face at me and all I remember thinking is I should get off when she does, trip her up, and get back on. I’ve repeatedly analyzed the way she looked at me and wonder would that happen now. The way things are going in the world, in this city even, would she have the audacity to look at me with the “Step up, bitch” face? I tend to think so, because she believed she was right. I was being ignorant and then had the nerve to look at her.
I started making up things I could say to rude people, depending on the situation so I would be prepared with a comeback. So many times people say they think of something witty days later. It’s ok. I’ve dedicated an entire class period to the Do Over.
One student redid a proposal (he did it publicly and regretted it immediately after). One redid an answer during a job interview that she was convinced was the reason she didn’t get hired. Of course we all know the proposal doesn’t change and the job is still not hers, but the exercise is rooted in catharsis. I have cussed the lady on the train out 14 different ways to Sunday and I’m not tired of it yet.
It may seem as though we’re feeding into a seeming inability to let go, and I agree about the letting go part, but not being unable. Voicing your do over makes it concrete. It makes you feel better when you get out the words you wish you would have said. I don’t look at it as a pointless exercise because if it brings someone any bit of closure or comfort to cuss out the bus driver who rudely closed the door and pulled off as soon as they got to the stop? Do it over and let him have it. Jerk.
